"The Man Had Been Stabbed from Within!"

HERE we have, right in the middle of the Golden Age of Detection (and Prohibition), nothing less than a brazen full-on assault on the genre (and the Volstead Act) by the staff of a popular magazine. An unjustifiable act of malice? No, we're more inclined to think they were all going bonkers waiting for the Eighteenth Amendment to be repealed . . .

"Mystery Number."

Judge Magazine, January 9, 1926 issue.

36 pages.

Online at Archive.org (HERE).

   "Within the deserted mansion itself, deserted save for a finger-print expert, a rifle-bore expert, a blood-stain expert, a toxicologist of note, a micrograph photographer, a score of plain clothes men and Inspector McGrouch—summoned hurriedly from his evening game of lotto, stood the Great Glumph, monosyllabic, hawklike, impenetrable."

WARNING! You'll need to have a high STQ (Silliness Tolerance Quotient) to get through this, so before you read it you might check with your psychiatrist—or, better yet, your wife . . .

Mystery references:

- Seven Baldpates (on the cover).

- The Black Hand (page 2).

- "The Amazing Adventures of Sherlock Lupin - A Tragedy of the Comic Weeklies" (pages 5 and 19).

- "Watson, the Needle!" (page 6).

- Mysterious trapdoor full-page cartoon (page 7).

- "The Midnight Crime" (page 8).

- "Stabbed from Within - A Glumph of the Bumps Yarn!" (pages 10 and 22-23).

- Mary Roberts Rinehart full-page cartoon (page 15).

- "The mystery story" cartoon (page 19).

- "The Return of Sherlock Holmes" (page 26).

- "Home Life of a Playwright" (page 27).

- "The Matrimonial Mystery" (page 29).

 

Resources:

- George Jean Nathan was a co-perpetrator of this issue of Judge; there's more about him (HERE).

- S. J. Perelman was also connected with Judge but not, evidently, with this particular issue; to make up for that, see his "Mastersleuth Unmasked at Last!" (HERE).

The bottom line:

Unless otherwise noted, all bibliographical data are derived from The FictionMags Index created by William G. Contento & edited by Phil Stephensen-Payne.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

"What Good's the Chocolate Maltese Falcon to a Venusian?"

. . . an excellent question, but you'll be lucky if you find the answer in . . .

"The Last Caper."

By Charles Beaumont (1929-67; Wikipedia HERE; the ISFDb HERE; the SFE HERE; and the IMDb HERE).

First appearance: Fantasy & Science Fiction, March 1954.

Reprints page (ISFDb HERE).

Short story (9 pages).

Online at SFFAudio (HERE).

   "When his hand came off and dropped to the floor, I knew I was in for some surprises myself."

SOME THINGS will never change, like tough-guy private eyes and deadly dames . . .

Main characters:

~ Bartholomew Cornblossom ("She planted one on my kisser and I felt all May and golden fields of ripe wheat and barefoot in soft river mud"), Mike Mallet ("He went down—fast—and began to whimper"), the secretary ("Next time open the door before you come through it, big boy"), 1742-A ("I don't dig getting beat; not by a robot, anyway"), and the green snake guy ("We shall see now how bravely the Earthling struts!"). 

Typo: "a Girl rom".

References:

- I, the Jury (HERE).

- The Martian Chronicles (HERE).

- Brancusi statuettes (HERE).

- Bromo-Seltzer (HERE).

- Sterno (HERE).

- Sonnets from the Portuguese (HERE).

- Botticelli's (HERE) Venus on the Half Shell (HERE).

- Coney (HERE) and (HERE).

Astronomical mentions:

- Mars and Martians (HERE).

- Venus and Venusians (HERE).

- Uranus and Uranians (HERE).

- Jupiter and Jovians (HERE).

- "Betelgeuseville" (HERE) and (HERE).

Resources:

- Another science fictional PI who forgot all about never taking cases from sexy dames can be found in Neil Gaiman's "The Case of the Four and Twenty Blackbirds" (HERE).

- Our only other encounter with Charles Beaumont was his "The Beautiful People," which was converted into a Twilight Zone episode (HERE).

The inspiration for our story.

Unless otherwise noted, all bibliographical data are derived from The FictionMags Index created by William G. Contento & edited by Phil Stephensen-Payne.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

"The Decadence of the Up-to-Date Gangster"

"Bad Man."

By O. O. McIntyre (1884-1938; Wikipedia HERE and the Smithsonian online magazine HERE).

First appearance: Cosmopolitan, February 1931.

True crime article (2 pages).

Online at Archive.org (HERE).

   "Gazing at them, at times I have thought I could give a few of them a tousling myself in a fair fight—but don’t count on me!"

"They don't make 'em like they used to" is an old saying that our author evidently heartily agrees with, as he compares and contrasts the criminal class of fifty years ago (1881) with those of the present day (1931) and finds the latest wild bunch deficient in so many ways. Like people who should know better, he shares a romantic nostalgia for those Wild West outlaws who did their dirty deeds with panache. If there had really been a Lone Ranger, this article probably wouldn't have been written . . .

References:

The respectable ones:

- Clinton County (HERE).

- Charles Lindbergh (HERE).

- The Pinkertons (HERE).

- Vincent Astor (HERE).

- The Prince of Wales (HERE).

- The Winter Garden Theatre (HERE).

- The George M. Cohan Theatre (HERE).

- Robin Hood (HERE). (We're ambivalent about this one.)

The respectable ones (to our author):

- Frank James (HERE).

- Jesse James (HERE).

- The James-Younger gang (HERE).

- Billy the Kid (HERE).

- Cole Younger (HERE).

Disreputable to almost everybody:

- The Rosenthal murder case (HERE).

- Charles Becker (HERE).

- Nathan Kaplan (HERE).

- Monk Eastman (HERE) and The Eastman Gang (HERE).

- Johnny Spanish (HERE).

- Max Zwerback (sic) (HERE).

- Jack Zelig (HERE).

- Arnold Rothstein and George "Hump" McManus (HERE).

- "Legs" Diamond (HERE).

Resource:

- O. O. McIntyre was your classic kid from the sticks reacting to the razzle-dazzle life in the Big City, and he milked it for all it was worth. He was often referred to as "Odd" McIntyre. In 1929 Cosmopolitan published a book collection of his stories (HERE).

The bottom line:

Unless otherwise noted, all bibliographical data are derived from The FictionMags Index created by William G. Contento & edited by Phil Stephensen-Payne.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

"Cherchez La Femme"

AT the start of our next story the author issues a sort of Queenian "Challenge to the Reader" before those became fashionable. Will you be able to solve . . .

"The Lauriston Mystery."

By Fred Jackson (1886-1953; Wikipedia HERE; the IBDb HERE; and the IMDb HERE).

First appearance: Munsey's Magazine, March 1929.

Novelette (22 pages; 3 illos).

Online at UNZ (good quality; HERE) and Archive.org (poor quality; HERE).

   ". . . she made a gesture with the dagger as though she were stabbing, and her face was like a tigress."

YOU couldn't get a better candidate for prime suspect than young, beautiful, and vigorous Miss Mills, the mere suggestion of which young, handsome, and vigorous Dr. Manning can't abide. But let's face it: she did have two hundred thousand reasons for doing it, and that death threat ain't helping her case one bit. As always, though, there's more here than meets the eye . . .

Comment: Unnecessarily attenuated by needless repetition. As for the mystery . . . elementary.

Principal characters:

~ Dr. Cyril Manning ("liked to diagnose illness without his subjects suspecting it, and to prognosticate, from signs invisible to laymen"), Dr. Oliver Wakefield ("I said nothing about normal or healthy"), Draga Mills ("glanced around like a caged bird, as if seeking moral support"), Mrs. Sarah Lipton ("He was no good at all, and everybody hereabouts knew it"), Bayard Lauriston ("was lying face downward upon the floor in a small pool of blood, near the corner of a huge table. He lay in a litter of books, papers, broken bric-a-brac"), Inspector Fowler ("I can well believe there were extenuating circumstances"), Brunton ("I thought so. Love letters!"), Abbey Smith ("Her eyes bulged as she recognized Inspector Fowler's uniform"), the coroner ("And yet"—the coroner spoke slowly, impressively—"you said in the presence of three gentlemen, now in this courtroom, when one of them informed you of Mr. Lauriston's death, 'I'm glad to hear it'"), and the coroner's jury ("We find that Mr. Bayard Lauriston was stabbed to death on the night of Friday, August thirteenth, by Miss Draga Mills, and recommend that she be held for trial on charge of murder in the first degree").

References:

- "strabismus" (HERE).

- "the Irene Castle bob" (HERE).

- "Correct Posture League" (HERE).

- "runabout" (HERE).

- "an old-fashioned open victoria" (HERE).

- "Robespierre" (HERE).

- "a picaresque hero" (HERE).

- "the tabloids" (HERE).

- "a Florentine dagger" (HERE).

- "the muck-rakers" (HERE).

- "a 'morgue'" (HERE).

- "Sing Sing" (HERE).

- "the River Jordan" (HERE).

Resource:

- FictionMags in re Frederick John Jackson: "Playwright, novelist, producer for stage, screen and television. Born in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania; died in Hollywood, California."

The bottom line:

Unless otherwise noted, all bibliographical data are derived from The FictionMags Index created by William G. Contento & edited by Phil Stephensen-Payne.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

"Drop Dead!"

THE THEME of someone suddenly gaining extraordinary power and having problems dealing with it is an old one (e.g., King Midas, the sorcerer's apprentice, etc.), which has been beaten into the ground more recently by Hollywood and Spandex superhero fiction. The question of the moment is whether the nebbish in today's story will be able to cope when he gets . . .

"The Power."

(a.k.a. "Rebound" in reprints).

By Fredric Brown (1906-72; Wikipedia HERE; the ISFDb HERE; the SFE HERE; and the IMDb HERE).

First appearance: Galaxy, April 1960.

Reprints page (ISFDb HERE).

Short short short story (3 pages).

Online at SFFAudio (HERE).

   ". . . he decided to take his time planning it so there would be no possibility of his making a careless mistake."

A once well-known public person observed, "The power to do good is also the power to do harm." Are you listening, Larry?

Main characters:

~ Larry Snell ("Why shouldn't he really use what he had?") and a top dame ("Rich men and handsome playboys were after her"). 

References:

- "the whammy" (Merriam-Webster HERE).

- "a relatively uncrowded part of the Catskills" (Wikipedia HERE).

Resources:

- Our story isn't to be confused with Frank M. Robinson's 1956 novel with a similar theme (HERE) or the 1968 movie made from it (Wikipedia; WARNING! SPOILERS! HERE), much 

less the 2021 British film (HERE).

- Our latest contact with Fredric Brown wasn't so long ago, namely his "The Jabberwocky Murders" (HERE).

The bottom line:

  Quando Omni Flunkus Moritati.

Unless otherwise noted, all bibliographical data are derived from The FictionMags Index created by William G. Contento & edited by Phil Stephensen-Payne.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

"Only You Stand Between Order and Destruction"

TODAY'S author passed away last December. Wikipedia tells us that his "writing style is distinctive, frequently employing long, elaborate sentences with few commas. Most of his science fiction books are short, present-tense narratives concerned exclusively with the consciousness of a single obsessive character." He left us a typical example of his stylistics with . . .

"Trashing."

By Barry N. Malzberg (1939-2024; Wikipedia HERE; the ISFDb HERE; the SFE HERE; the IMDb HERE; and Locusmag.com HERE).

First appearance: Infinity Five, 1973.

Reprints page (ISFDb HERE).

Short short short story (5 pages).

Online at The Luminist Archives (HERE; go to text page 64).

   ". . . I felt the passion to murder as I had never known it . . ."

IF there's a fine line between zealotry and madness, good luck finding it . . .

Principal characters:

~ "I" ("I'll get him and save us all"), the Committee ("Only you can destroy the madman"), and the madman ("You seem to be upset or angry, is something wrong?").

References:

- "Like Medusa" (Wikipedia HERE).

- Are we being told the truth, or are we being beguiled by one of (THESE)?

The bottom line:

Unless otherwise noted, all bibliographical data are derived from The FictionMags Index created by William G. Contento & edited by Phil Stephensen-Payne.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

"I Wouldn't Jump Too Hastily to Conclusions, Sergeant"

"Circumstantial Evidence."

By Traill Stevenson (1889-1968).

First appearance: T.P.'s & Cassell's Weekly, May 3, 1924.

Short short short story (3 pages).

Online at Hathi Trust starting (HERE), continuing (HERE), and finishing (HERE).

(Note: Text may need magnification.)

   "This is what actually happened, according to my 'reconstruction' . . ."

THERE ARE people who spend an inordinate amount of their time conclusion-jumping, which normally isn't a matter of life or death, but for someone accused of murder it can be a poten-tially fatal attitude, particularly in a police detective . . .

Main characters:

~ Reginald Trevelyan ("had been killed by the blow of a sharp, heavy instrument"), Dr. Waters ("such a wound could not have been self-inflicted"), Sergeant McIntosh ("It's as clear as daylight"), Henri de Balbois ("the gentleman to whom she had sent the incriminating letter"), the maid ("appeared very considerably distraught at my questions, and seemed to be afraid to say either yes or no"), Johnstone, the butler ("I remembered before the master came home, and put it right then"), Mrs. Trevelyan ("a slight, rather faded-looking woman of over fifty whose eyes were red from weeping"), and Detective Denver Stretton ("There was an expres-sion of quiet satisfaction on his face").

Bonus in the same issue:

A review of Sir Edward Abbott Parry's The Drama of the Law (HERE).

Resources:

- About Traill Stevenson FictionMags says: "Businessman who lived variously in Glasgow, Birkenhead and Harrow; Liberal candidate for Parliament in the 1920s; editor for some time of the Lloyd George Liberal Magazine."

- Other stories by Stevenson (FictionMags data; ss = short story):

 "Growing Old," (ss) T.P.’s and Cassell’s Weekly, March 22, 1924

 "Iyaaka’s God," (ss) The Sovereign Magazine, September 1924

 "The Sinister Half Wellingtons," (ss) Hutchinson’s Adventure-Story Magazine, March 1927.

The bottom line:

Unless otherwise noted, all bibliographical data are derived from The FictionMags Index created by William G. Contento & edited by Phil Stephensen-Payne.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~