"The Classic Semerák Case."
By Josef Škvorecký (1924-2012; Wikipedia HERE; The Canadian Encyclopedia HERE; and Murder & Mayhem HERE).
Series character: Lieutenant Borůvka.
First appearance: Unknown.
Reprinted in Ellery Queen's Mystery Magazine, October 1967 (today's text).
Short story (15 pages).
Online at The Luminist Archives (HERE; go to text page 80).
"Our complete investigative technique is based on system, on strict order, so we criminologists can't allow ourselves to be guided by haphazard ideas the way they do in detective books."
IT'S the classic dilemma: Was it murder or a suicide? A gung-ho police investigator is grimly determined to find out. All he has to do is to confirm that his hypotheses about S-B, B-T, and T-S are congruent with B-S-T, T-S-T, and B-S-B-T, and how all that fits with a half-hour visit to the Men's Room . . .
Principal characters:
~ Constable First Class Šinták ("was firmly convinced that Lieutenant Borůvka wielded powers not entirely in keeping with normal human abilities"), Sergeant Málik ("our insurance is the modern science of criminology"), Semerák ("you can tell that fellow's a murderer a mile off"), Pěnkava ("saw her alive!"), Bárta ("claims Semerák wore a tweed jacket"), old lady Bárta ("insists it was a brown corduroy jacket"), and Lieutenant Borůvka ("You didn't move a thing—everything is exactly the way you found it?").
References:
- "the Lindbergh kidnaping" (HERE).
- "the Sacco-Vanzetti story" (HERE).
Resources:
- Wikipedia (HERE) tells us about Josef Škvorecký's series character:
"He wrote four books of detective stories featuring Lieutenant Borůvka of the Prague Homicide Bureau: The Mournful Demeanor of Lieutenant Borůvka, Sins for Father Knox
[3 stories only], The End of Lieutenant Borůvka and The Return of Lieutenant Borůvka."
- Škvorecký deliberately set out to break every Golden Age of Detection rule that an English cleric considered inviolable with his Sins for Father Knox, which is available online (HERE; borrow only).
A thoughtful review of Sins for Father Knox appeared in the Los Angeles Times (HERE):
"What I experienced was a bout of ho-hummery, probably because I was hoping his rule-breaking exercises would be both fascinating and comprehensible. Instead, I found them tedious and opaque.
"And that’s a pity because the stories have a sound and even enviable premise: A beautiful and sexy Czech blues singer solves crimes that the police of several nations can’t solve. But Skvorecky has burdened his premise with an overweight gimmick--the breaking of Father Knox’s whimsical rules--and the gimmick finally crushes the premise."
- Note: If you're thinking of buying any of Josef Škvorecký's books in fine condition, be prepared to pay a pretty penny.
The bottom line:
Unless otherwise noted, all bibliographical data are derived from The FictionMags Index created by William G. Contento & edited by Phil Stephensen-Payne.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~