Friday, January 10, 2014

"A Winning Mystery"

EXIT A STAR.
By Kathleen Moore Knight (1890-1984).
Crime Club.
1941. 306 pages. $2.00
Current first edition price as high as $125.00
Chances are you never heard of her, but Knight was a prolific crime fiction and mystery author. These reviews discuss the second of four books featuring her series sleuth, Margot Blair:
Knight packs a lot into 300 pages. Backbiting, secret relationships, blackmail, betrayal and a murderer who, of course, just can't stop with one death. Add a dash of humour ("I see cactus is being worn this season") and a killer whose identity is well-hidden and you have a winning mystery. — Darrell, THE STUDY LAMP (6 February 2012)
Observant girl press-agent saves stage-struck deb from death and writes finis to murderous career of Long Island triple slayer. - Highly atmospheric item, with stage and publicity personalities well handled, nearly guess-proof plot, and gobs of action. - Verdict: High voltage. — THE SATURDAY REVIEW (November 15, 1941)
Resource:
- For short reviews of twenty-nine other Knight mysteries go HERE and follow the links.

Category: Detective fiction

"Between the Chicken Soup and the Schnecken"

MY MOTHER, THE DETECTIVE: THE COMPLETE "MOM" SHORT STORIES.
By James Yaffe (b. 1927).
Crippen & Landru.
1997. 174 pages.
Probably one of the most offbeat detectives to appear in fiction:
This modern version of the armchair detective story ["Mom in the Spring," 1954] is as impressive as the old traditional ones of Christie and Boucher and Orczy. Meticulously plotted, ingenious building up of the puzzle, fairly presented clues, thought provoking questions posed by Mom to her son who is presenting the case to her over dinner, Mom's supreme capability of reading between the lines and unraveling of the puzzle plot with her deep insight into the human nature to reveal an entirely different aspect to the case which was hitherto camouflaged—all add up for a most interesting read. — Arun Kumar, THE INGENIOUS GAME OF MURDER (March 3, 2012)
[James] Yaffe's fiction is filled with careful deductive work. Each story has a series of questions asked by Mom, wherein she uses her growing understanding of the crime to make guesses about the crime's circumstances. These passages are virtuosic. The end of the story shows Mom going over clues embedded in the tale. Yaffe shows an inventiveness in coming  up with these. It is a full measure of puzzle plot mystery. . . . Most . . . EQMM [Ellery Queen's Mystery Magazine] authors [such as Yaffe] wrote very pure armchair detective tales. One or more people would bring a problem to the detective character, who would then ask a few questions, then immediately solve the case. There would be no lapse of time, and the detective would not send the other characters out to do further sleuthing. Furthermore, the solution would be very carefully based on reasoning about the crime. Deduction would reign supreme. — Mike Grost, A GUIDE TO CLASSIC MYSTERY AND DETECTION ("James Yaffe")
James Yaffe, right, with one half of "Ellery Queen."
Mom never wanted her son Dave to become a policeman. "For all the brains it takes, believe me, you might as well be in business with your uncles." Besides, "All those gangsters and dope fiends and bookies and hatchet murderers and other such goniffs; isn't it possible you could get hurt some day?" It's not difficult to solve crimes, Mom explains—and it's certainly not for her. 
Dave and his very superior, Wellesley-educated wife, Shirley, have dinner with Mom in the Bronx every Friday evening. Between the chicken soup and the schnecken, Dave talks about his current cases. Mom is not interested in what she describes as sophie-ological analysis and psycho-annihilating the suspects, but her long experience in dealing with scheming butchers, nosey neighbors, and eccentric relatives leads her to a logical solution to all Dave's mysteries. "By yourself, you should've guessed it," Mom says, but it takes Mom's insight into personality to unravel the crime. 
Thirty years ago, Ellery Queen wrote that it was "sure as death and 'tectives" that a collection of Mom short stories would appear. Witty, wise, and filled with warmth, the Mom tales are some of the finest armchair detective stories ever written. — Cover blurb for My Mother, the Detective (1997)
The armchair detective of this book has no name. She is just called "Mom" by her son, David, a police detective of New York Homicide Squad. David regularly visits Mom with his wife, Shirley. At the dinner table, he talks about the murder cases he hasn't solved yet. Mom just listens to her son's stories, asks several questions and brilliantly solves the cases.
Excellently plotted mysteries. Every small piece fits neatly like a fine jig-saw puzzle. What is more, Mom's reasoning is backed up by her deep insight of human beings. She reveals people's weakness, foolishness, sadness and so on. That adds . . . depth and warmth. The stories . . . mainly consist [of] dialogue and [are] very easy to read, but they are deep and impressive. — APRICOT "ryoko"

Category: Detective fiction

Thursday, January 9, 2014

"A Clock That Wasn't There"

"The Adventure of the Mad Tea Party."
By Ellery Queen.
Short story.
First published in Red Book Magazine, October 1934. Collected in THE ADVENTURES OF ELLERY QUEEN (1934).
Filmed for TV in 1975.
"Well, there it is. You've just found out something that I've known since late yesterday: that [DELETED] is dead and that one of the people in the library killed him. But how, and why, and when—and I guess, more to the point, who? Now the key to the solution involves a clock that wasn't there—or if it was, why didn't I see its reflection in the mirror? You got the answer? Let's find out."
Easily one of the most popular EQ stories, and it saw life on film:
Richard Owen has invited Ellery Queen to his son's birthday party. The theme for the party is Alice in Wonderland and all the major characters of the story are busy rehearsing for the next day's event. Ellery spends a restless night, stumbles into a strange room during the night when he is looking for the library, an event which helps him later to solve the case of the missing Mad Hatter. — Arun Kumar, THE INGENIOUS GAME OF MURDER (March 12, 2012)
I've always liked mysteries that connect themselves in wacky ways with nursery rhymes and children's stories, and this is among the best of them. The cousins must also [have] enjoyed theatrics among their repertoire of mystery tricks, for when Ellery manages to reach an isolated friend's home in the hinterlands on Long Island—on a dark and rainy night, yet—he's confronted with the other guests acting out their roles in a scene from Alice in Wonderland.
And when the host mysteriously disappears during the night, and mysterious packages beginning arriving—all connected with Alice once again—it makes for one of the cleverest detective stories in the entire collection. Did I mention one scene in which the entire party is drugged and falls asleep for several hours? I should have.
I don't think that many people will catch on to what's going on in this one. It's a beauty. — Steve Lewis, from a review of The Adventures of Ellery Queen (1934), MYSTERY*FILE (29 February 2008)
The TV adaptation has also proven quite popular:
"The Mad Tea Party" (1934) is a classic of misdirection. EQ picked it as his best short story; after Agatha Christie's "The Affair at the Bungalow," it is the subtlest and most deceptive of all detective short stories. It was made into a superb and faithful TV show, as an episode of the 1975 Jim Hutton Ellery Queen TV series. The story was first broadcast October 30, 1975, and was scripted by Peter S. Fischer and directed by James Sheldon. — Mike Grost, A GUIDE TO CLASSIC MYSTERY AND DETECTION ("The Adventures of Ellery Queen")
The murder in this one is not official until the end of the show. It is officially a disappearance. Ellery is right in the middle of it as he alone has to put together the clues that lead to the killer. Interesting that the Mad Hatter is the missing one. Queen actually plays the suspects like a parlor game to solve this one. A top notch episode in the series, not to be missed. — DKOSTY, IMDb
"The Adventure of the Mad Tea Party" is, shockingly enough, the only regular episode from the entire series to be based on an actual short story by Ellery Queen. It's also one of the best episodes of the series. . . And—best of all!—this episode represents Jim Hutton's best performance yet as Ellery. — Nathanael Booth, MORE MAN THAN PHILOSOPHER (24 February 2011)
If you happen to watch the show, note the sly use of character names: Lockridge, Biggers, Gardner, Doyle, Allingham, Rinehart, Carr.

Category: Detective fiction

Murder Will Out

"Private Eye."
By Lewis Padgett [Henry Kuttner and, possibly, C. L. Moore].
Long short story.
First published in Astounding, January 1949.
Online HERE.
"He could defy it. The Eye couldn't read thoughts. He bought the gun and lay in wait for Vanderman in a dark alley. But first he got thoroughly drunk. Drunk enough to satisfy the Eye."
"Actus non facit reum, nisi mens sit rea" versus "Acta exteriora indicant interiora secreta." It's the future, when the past is an open book and the Eye is always looking over your shoulder in . . .
. . . a world where we have a device that can see & hear things happening anywhere in the past . . . Cops use it in investigations. But they cannot see inside your mind—they can only observe your external actions. How do you kill someone & get acquitted, in spite of the fact that cops will see & hear everything you did—including your life before the crime? — Tinkoo Valia, VARIETY SF (February 23, 2009)

Categories: Science fiction, Detective fiction

Wednesday, January 8, 2014

Hoch's Locked Room Winner

"The Oblong Room."
By Edward D. Hoch (1930-2008).
Short story (10 pages).
First published in The Saint Magazine, July 1967.
Online at Archive.org (HERE).

One of nearly a thousand short stories by Hoch:
Captain Leopold joins his Sergeant to investigate an open and shut case of murder in the college hostel. Ralph Rollings has been found stabbed to death. His roommate Tom McBern was found enclosed with the dead man for 24 hours and he is not willing to make a statement. The only thing they need to convict Tom is a motive and the whole investigation is based on finding that motive. — Arun Kumar, THE INGENIOUS GAME OF MURDER (March 17, 2012)
Captain Jules Leopold is a police detective, the head of the Violent Crimes Squad of the police department of an unnamed city in Connecticut. Along with his colleagues Lieutenant Fletcher and Sergeant Connie Trent, he is one of Hoch's most conventional characters. The Leopold stories are police procedurals on the surface, showing the interaction of the officers as they investigate crimes, but the crimes themselves are frequently unusual and reflect Hoch's skill at plotting and placement of clues. The story outcomes usually depend on the deductive ability of Leopold and his comrades rather than on straightforward police work, and sometimes feature impossible crimes and locked rooms. — Wikipedia
What was the friend of the victim doing, locked in a room with the body for three days after the death? This story serves as a reminder that, just like Erle Stanley Gardner, Edward D. Hoch was not just a fiction factory, but a brilliant, brilliant writer. — Bookflings
. . . Captain Leopold has survived through nearly fifty years and over a hundred stories. He's Captain of Police in a small Connecticut city not unlike Hoch's own hometown of Rochester, New York. These are seldom simple police procedurals, though. Leopold comes up against some of the most bizarre mysteries, including a number of 'impossible' crimes.
One of the strangest, though, is the story that won Hoch his first - and rather surprisingly only Edgar Award to date - where what ought to be a simple case of stabbing at a university takes a bizarre twist leading to a chilling revelation. Hoch remarked: " 'The Oblong Room'  was rejected by EQMM and AHMM before finding a home at The Saint. Apparently the religious aspects scared off some editors, although I understand that it won mainly because Anthony Boucher, chairman of the short story committee that year, really pushed for it. Boucher was a devout Catholic, so obviously there was nothing about the story that offended him." — Mike Ashley, GOLDEN AGE MYSTERIES FORUM (August 7, 2006)
Edward D. Hoch’s short story "The Oblong Room" is another classic example of a locked-room mystery. Again, this story features a victim found within a room that is literally locked up. In that story, Captain Leopold, a Connecticut police chief, is called to the local university campus, where the body of Ralph Rollings has been found with stab wounds. His roommate, Tom McBern, is found in the room, too, and has apparently been there with the body for two days. Captain Leopold tries to unravel the mystery behind McBern’s odd behavior, but at first, nobody’s talking, including a girl they both liked, and friends of both young men. When Leopold finally unravels this “locked-room” mystery, the motive for the murder, and the story behind it, provide the real surprise. — Margot Kinberg, CONFESSIONS OF A MYSTERY NOVELIST (December 8, 2009)
Resource:
- Steve Lewis's interview with Edward D. Hoch.

Category: Detective fiction

Tuesday, January 7, 2014

"Dawdling and Prolixity"

MRS. VANDERSTEIN'S JEWELS.
By Mrs. Charles Bryce (1839-1920).
John Lane Co.
1914. 344 pages. 6s.
Available on Kindle.
Online HERE, HERE, and HERE.

Here's the full review (THE NATION, September 3, 1914):
Mrs. Vanderstein was the still comely widow of a Jewish money-lender, and had the habit of wearing a king's ransom in jewels. It therefore befell her to be lured into a strange house and murdered. The manner of her taking-off was, we regret to say, rather tame and commonplace, since she was merely chloroformed like a cat. In disposing of the body, however, the murderers really achieved the sort of novelty called for in this order of fiction. They hit upon a new place for an inconvenient corpse, namely, a large, a very large flowerbox on a balcony. The pot of basil, with its dolorous skull, is quite outdone.
How Gimblet, the detective, discovers the house, the crime, the box, the body, and the murderers, is the substance of the story. Gimblet, with his languor, his connoisseurship, and his inductive method—or is it deductive?—bears a somewhat striking resemblance to Dr. Watson's Sherlock. He carries a microscope, and a set of pill-boxes in which he solemnly deposits bits of dust, hairs, and the like. Nothing escapes him, not even the murderer. This is all as it should be, for the purpose.
Detective stories are commonly reducible to formula, and the Sherlock recipe is better than most. But in Conan Doyle's own hands it has proved better adapted to short stories than to a mystery novel. Much of the great Holmes's glamour is due to the celerity of his method. This Gimblet is a dawdling gentleman and a garrulous, more, as it seems, by the author's fault than his own. If anything is fatal to a tale of mystery, it is dawdling and prolixity. The material in this book might have been condensed into a fairly effective short story.
Another review (THE SPECTATOR, 5 September 1914), a one-liner:
Few will be able to solve this admirable detective story, the only fault of which is its excessive length.

Category: Detective fiction.

Monday, January 6, 2014

"Measuring the Shudder"

THE TECHNIQUE OF THE MYSTERY STORY.
By Carolyn Wells.
The Writer's Library.
1913. 336 pages. $1.50
Available on Kindle.
Online HERE, HERE, HERE, HERE (scanned), and HERE.

Contents:
I. "The Eternal Curious"
II. "The Literature of Mystery"
III. "The History of Mystery"
IV. "Ghost Stories"
V. "Riddle Stories"
VI. "Detective Stories"
VII. "The Detective"
VIII. "Deduction"
IX. "Applied Principles"
X. "The Rationale of Ratiocination"
XI. "Close Observation"
XII. "Other Detectives of Fiction"
XIII. "Portraits"
XIV. "Devious Devices"
XV. "Footprints and Fingerprints"
XVI. "More Devices"
XVII. "Fake Devices"
XVIII. "Murder in General"
XIX. "Persons in the Story"
XX. "The Handling of the Crime"
XXI. "The Motive"
XXII. "Evidence"
XXIII. "Structure"
XXIV. "Plots"
XXV. "Further Advices"
XXVI. "Final Advices".

In his article (not strictly speaking a review), this particular critic finds it hard to take Wells's book of advice seriously and has mild objections to some of her opinions. A few excerpts follow:
One of the most readable of all [the books about the short story] is "The Technique of the Mystery Story," by Carolyn Wells (Home Correspondence School). In spite of many passages in fine print, I cannot imagine any one leaving it unfinished, once having begun to read it. Yet, when you see it announced as "a complete practical study of the form, with examples from the best mystery writers," you not only smile, but feel sure that the author smiled, too.
The table of contents is delicious, and the index irresistible. Chapter IV, for instance, the table tells us, is about ghost stories, and it is divided into four parts: a working classification, the ghost story, famous ghost stories, the humorous ghost story. Against attempting the last, by the way, the novice is warned. Chapter XIV deals with Devious Devices, as tracks in the snow or mud. Another speaks of footprints and fingerprints, with a note on teeth-marks. Another describes disguises and discusses the literary value of false whiskers.
Miss Wells makes some surprising statements. "A true lover of detective fiction,"' she writes, "never reads detailed newspaper accounts of crime." This, I fancy, is altogether too sweeping. Certainly, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle—who loves detective fiction so well that he writes a great deal of it—has become interested in real crimes, and presumably through the newspapers. The Edalji and Slater cases have occupied him at home, and during his recent visit in New York he expressed his interest in the Becker case and sought an interview with the convicted man.
It is possible to carry one's hostility to the adage "Truth is stranger than fiction" too far, and this Miss Wells does when she declares Arthur C. Train's "True Stories of Crime" dull and prosy. As a rule, of course, the fictitious is more entertaining than the true, but it is certainly unsafe to declare that this is always and invariably the case. — Edmund Lester Pearson, "Measuring the Shudder," THE NATION (July 9, 1914)
Read the article to find out why Pearson believes Sherlock Holmes is superior to both Dupin and The Thinking Machine.

Category: Detective fiction