Monday, January 6, 2014

Praise for Rinehart

THE BREAKING POINT.
By Mary Roberts Rinehart (1876-1958).
George H. Doran.
1922. 356 pages. $2.00
Online HERE and HERE.
To judge from these critics' enthusiastic reactions, Rinehart might as well have retired from writing after publishing this book (which today would be classed as a Gothic romance) because she would likely never do any better. Did she "transcend the genre" long before the term was invented? Brief excerpts below:
WITHOUT any question, "The Breaking Point" is the most thoroughly absorbing novel for sheer story value that I have read in months. Written with a sure knowledge of the technique of plot building, an unfailing use of the dramatic, a deft sense of characterization, and a clever interweaving of sentiment, it again assures us that Mrs. Rinehart has an increasingly intuitive vision. It is a mystery story, yes. It is a love story, yes. It will make an excellent moving picture, yes. But it is more than that, it is a vivid portrayal of the fact that each one of us has an inner self, another self, around which we learn to build up a screen—a screen through which we fear to have our neighbors look, a screen through which we are finally unable to look ourselves. — THE BOOKMAN (September 1922)
From thousands of hearts and homes the cry will go up this summer: Thank God for Mary Roberts Rinehart! — THE NEW REPUBLIC (August 23, 1922)
My last Mary Roberts Rinehart book of the year, and while it may not be what many would consider a true mystery, I couldn't be happier with ending the year on such a high note. . . .The Breaking Point is more of a Gothic like romance, with a tinge more mystery than would normally be suspected. Once again, and I should have know better by now, I wasn't expecting the focus to be on the personal relationships so much, but I didn't care. Mary Roberts Rinehart is so brilliant at creating characters and relationships between them, that I would be willing to read just about anything by her. — Ryan, WORDSMITHONIA (December 6, 2012)
Even a British reviewer can't refrain from bestowing faint praise upon THE BREAKING POINT:
Though we do not know if this novel has actually appeared in serial form, it has the ineradicable marks of such an origin. A recurrent state of irritation or suspense (a sort of seven-days' fever), an alternation of homely and adventurous incident, the whole soused in a wash of antiseptic emotion, mark the high-water of narrative skill as it is at present most appreciated. But there is certainly a pleasure in seeing anything efficiently done, and this, like most of the importations from America, is points ahead of our native product as regards workmanship. — THE SPECTATOR (4 November 1922)

Category: Detective fiction

A Stitch in Crime

THE CRIME DOCTOR.
By E. W. Hornung.
Bobbs-Merrill.
1914. 315 pages. $1.35
Story collection: 8 stories.
Online HERE.

Contents:
I. "The Physician Who Healed Himself"
II. "The Life-Preserver"
III. "A Hopeless Case"
IV. "The Golden Key"
V. "A Schoolmaster Abroad"
VI. "One Possessed"
VII. "The Doctor's Assistant"
VIII. "The Second Murderer"

Don't expect much mystery from the creator of Raffles and the brother-in-law of Conan Doyle, just lots of adventure. Abstractions from longer reviews follow; use the links for more:
This is a collection of stories based on the experiments of a man who has himself been cured of a criminal tendency by an operation on the brain. — THE OUTLOOK (August 1914)
. . . Mr. Hornung has happily endowed [his main character] with the instincts of a detective as well as with those of a social reformer, and the result is that the half-dozen [sic] stories in this book are sufficiently readable to beguile pleasantly an idle hour. — THE NATION (August 13, 1914; scroll to page 194, middle)
Mr. E. W. Hornung is fortunate in the possession of a fertile imagination, which enables him at fairly regular intervals to produce new and whimsical personalities, whose chief attraction is their paradoxical ability to reverse the established order of things. In Raffles, for instance, he gave us the counterpart, of Sherlock Holmes. The detective who never fails to catch the criminal is a familiar figure in fiction; but the criminal whom no detective can catch is a distinct innovation. And now Mr. Hornung has given us still another novelty in what he chooses to call The Crime Doctor. The conventional detective exists for the purpose of protecting the public by detecting and punishing the criminal; the Crime Doctor, on the contrary, devotes himself to the more difficult task of anticipating the crime, and protecting the would-be criminal against himself. The numerous adventures of Dr. Dollar, the expert in this sort of divination, are extremely varied, sometimes quite ingenious, and occasionally verge upon the borderline of farce-comedy. — THE BOOKMAN (September 1914; scroll to page 96; SPOILERS)
THE CRIME DOCTOR was critically acclaimed when first published but unfortunately Dr. Dollar’s thrilling adventures came to a halt shortly after because of the death of the author. Such the pity because the Crime Doctor is an intriguing character, one whom could stand shoulder to shoulder with Sherlock Holmes, Charlie Chan, Philo Vance as well as Hornung’s most popular creation, Raffles, the Gentleman Cracksmith. — NEW YORK BOOK TIME (March 10, 2008)

Category: Detective fiction

Friday, January 3, 2014

Death Steals the Scene

MURDER IN THREE ACTS.
By Agatha Christie.
Dodd, Mead.
1934. $2.00
Filmed for TV in 2010 (IMDb).
Available on Kindle.
[a.k.a. THREE ACT TRAGEDY]
The following brief excerpts will refer to both the book at times and the TV show at others:
Cleric, nerve specialist, invalid die from nicotine poisoning but Hercule Poirot spots the envenomer. - M. Poirot's little gray cells start functioning so late in book that suspense changes to exasperation and ennui. - Verdict: Not so good. — THE SATURDAY REVIEW (October 6, 1934)
A Christie which feels more like an Anthony Berkeley, with its cast of socialites, intellectuals and theatricals, its opening murder at a cocktail party, and both the murderer's identity and his gambit. Throughout, Christie's writing is witty and sophisticated, and the characterisation of the leading roles is very good. Although Poirot is present when an inoffensive clergyman is poisoned at a cocktail party given by the actor Sir Charles Cartwright, he doesn't really begin to detect properly until page 117. The murderer's identity is quite surprising, although it's one Christie will use several times throughout the 1930s. His plan, though, is improbable and very risky. — Nick Fuller, GAD Wiki
Although a conceited elderly bachelor such as Poirot had limited scope for development, Christie abandoned the Holmesian ambience and turned her detective's traits cleverly to advantage. In Three Act Tragedy (1935; Murder in Three Acts), he acknowledged that speaking broken English was an enormous asset, which tempted suspects to under estimate him and thus let their guard slip. Christie was not afraid to poke fun at him, but in his "bourgeois" disapproval of murder he reflected her attitudes. — Martin Edwards ("Hercule Poirot")
This is a story of coincidences, quite a number of false trails, and one in which both Mr. Satterthwaite and Hercule Poirot play the matchmaker. Poirot is determined that the mystery will not defeat him. He is very aggrieved that he did not originally think [the first victim] was murdered. — Kerrie, MYSTERIES IN PARADISE (9 January 2010)
. . . I think the concept behind the book is marvellously cunning—especially in the way the first murder is explained—and as far as I know it is original to Christie. A clever mystery, turned into splendid Sunday evening viewing. — Martin Edwards, DO YOU WRITE UNDER YOUR OWN NAME? (4 January 2010)
The film has been unfairly assailed as being "too theatrical." Indeed, theatricality is a welcome component of the production. Kudos to director Ashley Pearce for making intelligent use of just about every visual technique known to film makers to keep things moving; the pacing is excellent and the performances—particu-lary by Kimberley Nixon, Martin Shaw, and David Suchet—are most effective. — Mike Tooney

Category: Detective fiction

Nick and Nora in Everything but Name

THE EX-MRS. BRADFORD.
RKO.
1936. 82 minutes.
Available on DVD.
If this screwball comedy-mystery reminds you of The Thin Man series, that's probably no coincidence:
As things get underway Bradford is drawn into the investigation of the murder of a jockey, while also dealing with the ramifications of the sudden and unexpected return of his ex-wife. A few more murders break out along the way, Bradford gets roughed up on more than one occasion, and the couple end up coming to a truce and reuniting. — William I. Lengeman III, TRADITIONAL MYSTERIES (December 21, 2011)
Beyond its two leads, The Ex-Mrs. Bradford shares similarities with other popular films of the period. It's got the screwball estranged husband and wife who clearly belong together after all; the married couple at the center of a tale combining the dark, often gruesome elements of a crime story with the breezy romantic comedy typical of the time; the madcap society girl who won't mind her own business, nearly bringing ruin on the object of her affections; and the wise-cracking butler. Even as early as 1936, critics were saying The Ex-Mrs. Bradford was covering "fearfully familiar ground," and yet most were delighted to report that the work of everyone involved made it all seem fresh and novel. — Rob Nixon, TCM
A little dialogue:

  "I didn't know you went in for opening safes, Doc."
  "Oh, we surgeons open anything."
----------------------------------------------------
  "I like things the way they are now. I can pick up my paper in the morning, read about a murder, and enjoy it."
------------------------------------------
  "Good morning, Doc."
  "Oh, good morning, Inspector."
  "You're looking pretty healthy for a corpse."

Category: Detective fiction (screwball division)

"A Deliciously Complex Mystery"

THE TAU CROSS MYSTERY.
By J. J. Connington (Alfred Walter Stewart, 1880-1947).
Little, Brown.
1935. $2.00
Reprinted in 2012.
[a.k.a. IN WHOSE DIM SHADOW]
Connington seems to be one of those capable mystery writers history has largely ignored. Following are brief excerpts from various sources:
Gent with unsavory past and gentle recluse shot in English flat. Sir Clinton Wendover [sic] from tiny clues catches killer. - A problem in deduction solved step by step with ubiquitous but elusive criminal—and a bit too much machinery. - Verdict: Staple goods. — THE SATURDAY REVIEW (July 6, 1935)
The mystery is cleverly contrived, with a neat story-line, not too much padding (though I admit the pace isn't electric) and a good solution. — Martin Edwards, DO YOU WRITE UNDER YOUR OWN NAME? (23 December 2011)
Another case for Driffield, with his Watson squire Wendover in tow. Suburban setting offers a nice change of pace. Solidly clued case, with a few surprisingly sympathetic character portraits and a kicker of a last paragraph. — Curt Evans, GAD Wiki
This is a deliciously complex mystery that is also fairly clued—scrupulously so, in fact. Every single piece of the puzzle fits together in the end, in a lovely, logical pattern. Sir Clinton goes over his investigations thoroughly and tosses ideas back and forth with his friend, Squire Wendover. Please don’t let that name fool you—Wendover isn’t an empty-headed sidekick like Agatha Christie’s bland Captain Hastings. He’s intelligent, shrewd, and observant—he notices small details that escape others, and he often manages to partially put together the pieces of the puzzle. Some of the best sections in the book are the sarcasm-laced conversations between Wendover and Sir Clinton, as they poke holes in their theories. — Patrick, AT THE SCENE OF THE CRIME (March 22, 2012)
J. J. Connington has suffered from the unfortunate belief that he was a highly ingenious deviser of puzzles but that his stories lacked any human warmth. . . Yet it is always to Connington's ingenious, carefully thought out and complicated problems that one returns. — Nick Fuller & Mike Grost, GAD Wiki
. . . Chief Constables are mainly shown at their desks [in Golden Age novels], getting reports and assigning men to the investigation. By contrast, Sir Clinton Driffield goes right out to crime scenes, making a full scale investigation. Driffield is especially skilled at discovering evidence at the scene, such as blood stains. He also is good at reconstructing crimes, based on these observations. He is much better at these tasks than any of the local police officers who work for him. — Mike Grost, A GUIDE TO CLASSIC MYSTERY AND DETECTION ("J. J. Connington")
Resource:
- A Wikipedia article ("Alfred Walter Stewart").

Category: Detective fiction

Thursday, January 2, 2014

"What the Police Read"

You'd think the average cop would appreciate all the help he could get, even if it comes from fiction writers, but according to this article from a hundred years ago (reproduced in full) you'd be wrong:
WHATEVER THE WORLD at large may think of detective stories, they do not win the esteem of those whose business it is to follow up crime. The police care least of all for this lie of literature—a fact discovered by reports of the books most favored among those consigned by the New York Public Library for use at the police stations. The New York Times, in commenting on this discovery, finds not much to wonder at:
"Possibly their selection of standard and classic books has been somewhat influenced by the opinion of the library authorities as to what they ought to read, that being an inclination of librarians everywhere. But the policemen, one is glad to see, have not been deprived of fiction, and they have waded through the old standbys, presumably with as much pleasure as any of us have felt—which is saying a good deal if only one gets at the orthodox masterpieces betimes.
"According to report, these particular readers find little of interest and nothing of profit in the 'detective stories' which have such a wide sale with the ununiformed public. The policemen say that 'real' detective work is not done after the fashion of the sagacious heroes of Conan Doyle and his predecessors, and therefore they scorn romantic crime-hunting. This condemnation involves the assumption that the methods of 'practical' men can not be bettered—an assumption wildly fallacious, but entirely natural. The police antagonism to detective novels may be due in some part to the fact that in almost every such book it is the scientific amateur who works all the miracles, while the 'headquarters man' is usually a comic character who laboriously follows a false clue while the other fellow gets the results.
"In reading a detective story, too, the policeman would be apt to forget that the object of fiction is to be plausible, rather than to be accurate as to petty details, and that a 'mistake' may be intentionally made by an author for the sake of attaining some higher end of emphasis or excitement. As a matter of fact, all the great advances in the task of crime-detection have been made, not by policemen, but by scientists. This is true, however, of so many professions and trades that 'the force' need not be humiliated by it, and if the policemen would show a little more of the romancer's willingness to understand and utilize the suggestions coming from the psychological laboratories, considerably less of their work would probably be unsuccessful." — Unsigned, "What the Police Read," THE LITERARY DIGEST (June 13, 1914)
The article is accompanied by a photograph captioned: "MR. AND MRS. CONAN DOYLE, WITH DETECTIVE BURNS. Is he telling Mr. Doyle what the police think of detective stories?"

Resource:
- A previous ONTOS article concerning real-life detective William J. Burns is HERE.

Category: Detective fiction

Wednesday, January 1, 2014

The Thaumaturgical Doyle

Did Sherlock Holmes possess the supremely brilliant mind that Conan Doyle was so anxious to have us believe he did? In this brief excerpt from a longer article on THE RAP SHEET (December 28, 2011), we see that James McCreet is quite frankly dubious:
There was always something slightly fishy about Sherlock Holmes' remarkable deductions. As Doctor John Watson himself often said, they seem easy after they've been explained, but impossible without Holmes' indulgent revelations. The impression is that if we could just learn to see like the Great Detective, we could emulate his powers.
In fact, Holmes' skill lies not in his method but in the narrative structure of Arthur Conan Doyle's now-famous stories. Like an illusionist, the writer asks us to look at the false hand (Watson) while the real hand (Doyle) is busy doing the "magic."
McCreet's skepticism notwithstanding, others point to Holmes's reasoning abilities as the epitome of detectival skill:
Doyle's puzzle plot stories are on the direct line that leads to the Intuitionist writers of the 20th century. . . . [Stories such as "The Naval Treaty"] display the ingenious plots that are the hallmark of the later Intuitionist school of Chesterton, Christie, Carr and Queen. Holmes also solves the cases by the methods to be used by the Intuitionist detectives: insight into the central aspects of the mysterious situation, combined with logical deduction. There is much emphasis on how Holmes solves the cases through pure thinking. The finale of "The Man with the Twisted Lip," where Holmes comes up with his solution through a night of pure thinking, seems paradigmatic of later Intuitionist writers. So does the use of logical deduction in "Silver Blaze" and "The Naval Treaty." In these works, Holmes shows how clues embedded in the tale logically imply that one and only one of the suspects is guilty of the crime. This approach will also be much used by later Intuitionist authors. — Mike Grost, A GUIDE TO CLASSIC MYSTERY AND DETECTION ("Sir Arthur Conan Doyle")
. . . we can conclude that Sherlock Holmes knew well the new probabilistic theory of scientific reasoning, and applied it, as his own method, to his criminal investigations. Moreover, since the major advocates of this new theory were also expert[s] of symbolic logic, we may conclude, in all probability, that Holmes knew Boolean symbolic logic as well. On the total evidence, the balance of probability is that he was a very good logician. — Soshichi Uchii
If Sherlock Holmes had written his textbook on the art of detection it would likely have been a textbook on theseology, that is, a textbook telling us how we should go about looking for clues and how to follow them. Many people can reason but not many can solve crimes. Sherlock Holmes may be the greatest reasoning machine in the world, but he is also the only consulting detective that the world has ever seen. If anyone should write a textbook on theseology he should. — Tyrone Lai (whose book, THE ART OF DETECTION, is online HERE)
Remember: When you're playing The Grandest Game in the World, it's no fun if you don't follow the rules.

Resource:
- YouTube video clip: 3 minutes 46 seconds (which might or might not still be there by the time you click on it).

Category: Detective fiction