By Ellery Queen (1905-71; 1905-82).
First appearance: Redbook Magazine, December 1936.
Artwork by William Reusswig.
Reprinted in Ellery Queen’s Mystery Magazine, June 1959; Ellery Queen’s Mystery Magazine (Australia), August 1959; and Ellery Queen’s Mystery Magazine (U.K.), August 1959.
Collected in The New Adventures of Ellery Queen (1940).
Short story (9 pages).
Online at Archive.org starting (HERE) and finishing (HERE).
"This business of the pilfered door-stop is provocative."When a well-to-do businessman disappears under a cloud of suspicion, that's one thing; but when a soapstone door-stop vanishes with him, it's enough to get Ellery Queen, pince-nezed supersleuth, searching for an even greater crime . . .
~ Mr. Jito Kagiwa:
"Only when ruin stared him in the eyes did his resolution waver, and then it was too late to do more than salvage the battered wreck."
"He must have gone crazy."
"I always said that slinky yellow devil would come to no good."
"But I've always been a fool, and I did open the door; and the moment I opened it and gawped like an idiot into the darkness, something hit me on the head."
"Look here, old man: What has that confounded door-stop to do with Kagiwa's disappear-ance?"
~ Mr. Ellery Queen:
"This mess of statistics means everything to me. Pity if it had been lost. It's like the Rosetta Stone—it's the key to an otherwise mystifying set of facts. The old adage was wrong. It isn't safety that you find in numbers, but enlightenment."
- Ellery Queen Reader at Reading Ellery Queen (HERE; SPOILERS) doesn't think much of this story:
"The plot is not too interesting, and neither are the characters, or even the mystery. Perhaps the cousins were finding that simple stories, without any need for complex thought, were the ones that popular magazines would pay top dollar for. Maybe Hollywood was beginning to take its toll on Ellery Queen."
HERE) thinks more highly of it:
". . . Ellery solves this case twice, as in 'The Teakwood Case' and The Greek Coffin Mystery. And once again, the two explanations interact in ingenious ways. The twin solutions are less complex than those of the earlier stories: this tale is constructed on a smaller scale than earlier works. But it is still a satisfying instance of Queen's imagination."